"Tom suggested that Mary (a. went ; b. go) to university". Which of the enclosed word is correct? Why?



Answers:
I'm symphathetic with those who suggest both are correct, but each has a different meaning. But there is a minor problem with (a), so if pressed to pick ONE I'd chose (b) "go".

Here's how it works:

b) "Tom suggested that Mary go to univerity." -- Correct. Meaning: Tom gave some advice -- that Mary should go to university. (The advice is directed to Mary, or to someone else who might influence Mary's actions.)

a) "Tom suggested that Mary went to university." This would mean, Tom HINTED to SOMEONE ELSE, or expressed aloud his GUESS, that Mary was, at the time of his speaking, attending university. (The suggestion is almost certainly NOT spoken to Mary, but to someone else about her .)

This is grammatically correct. But I'm not sure it's the most likely way someone would speak. It is somewhat more likely they would say:

c) "Tom suggested that Mary was going to university." (That is, she was a student attending there at the time he spoke about it.)
OR
d) "Tom suggested that Mary HAD GONE to university" (That is, she was a student some time BEFORE Tom's spoke about it.)
go. Went is a past tense verb, while go is a present tense verb. Yes, i know it sounds weird, but grammatically it is correct.
went. tom suggested, suggested is in the past tense therefore the verb must also be past tense.
b: go. went is past tense.
B. the answer is go. the why i can't clearly explain. too tired to think it out.
It depends on what you're trying to say!

If it's something Tom suggests that she's already done.went. If it's a plan for her to do in the the future..go.
b. Go is correct...
Because Tom has suggested something... And if Mary "Went", then it isnt a suggestion, its an event which has occured already..
it depends on if it was past tense or future tense. tom suggested that mary went to university when he was talking to rick. or tom suggested that mary go to university next year. it depends on the rest of the sentence
go
B. go
The suggestion infers that Mary hasn't gone to a university. Tom wouldn't suggest it if she was already enrolled in a university; unless Mary wants to change colleges. In that case.either could be correct! Trick question? In that case I would say a and b!
Go; went is just bad usage in the current format.

"Mary went to the university" works in that context
go. Cos it didn't happen yet.
The way I see it Tom suggested (in the past) Mary do something in the future. So correct word would be GO because she hasn't done it yet.
Oooh - I guess the jury is out on this one!

I thought initially a) went - past tense to agree with the past participle of suggest. Then I read through everyone's answers and stopped to ponder for a little while.

After much deliberation, I decided that a) went IS the right answer for a British person like myself. Using the word b) go in my opinion, would be using an Americanism.
I think they are both grammatically correct, but the meanings are different.
1) "Tom suggested that Mary (should) go to university" is a proposal of action. Tom thought she should go to university.
2) "Tom suggested that Mary went to university" sounds like Tom guessed that Mary had likely been to university based on the circumstance or information perceived by Tom.

What do others suggest?
I suggested both a or b were grammatically correct but with different meaning.
see... :)
went is correct
i think the formation of your sentence is wrong.
the sentence could be formed as, "Tom suggested Mary to go the University".but if you want to retain "that" in your sentence, then i think you could say it as, "Tom suggested that Mary had gone(or went) to the University.
"Tom suggested that Mary went to university" - here Tom has suggested that Mary should have started going to the university already.
"Tom suggested that Mary go to university" - here Tom has suggested that Mary should start going to the university now or in the near future.
So I guess that both are correct.
"Tom suggested that Mary go to university."

When the speaker begins to speak, he is talking about something that has already happened (past tense): Tom suggested...

Just as the speaker says 'suggested' (past tense), he shifts into the timeline that he is speaking about. For example, if Tom had said that yesterday evening, then after saying "Tom suggested", the speaker has properly moved into 'yesterday evening when Tom was saying whatever he was saying'.

Now the verbs that would follow -for- the action of 'Tom suggested' would be in the present tense. So all that 'Tom suggested' would be in the present tense. To elaborate on your sentence,

Tom suggested that Mary -go- to university and not -remain- at home.

Once the suggestion (action) is over, the speaker will again have to use past tense to turn the sentence pointer to another action in past (Mary's reply). Such as,

Tom suggested that Mary go to the university and not remain at home. Mary replied that she would -do- so.

Once the speaker's pointer turns the timeline to a certain main verb in past (replied), then all the 'actions' (verbs) arising from that would again be in present tense (do).
Go
it is "go" since the time at which tom was suggesting was for the future.

This article contents is post by this website user, EduQnA.com doesn't promise its accuracy.



More Questions & Answers...
  • How do you spell peanut?
  • Etymology: This is kind of backwards, but how can you find out what English words come from a Latin word?
  • What is the meaning of mother's maiden?
  • What does seduce mean?
  • Is there anywhere I can get a free downloadable dictionary/thesaurus?
  • Anagram One Word?
  • What is the difference between ballpen and inkpen?
  • What does the phrase new call mean?
  • Copyright 2006-2009 EduQnA.com All Rights Reserved.